Hamilton Halton Construction Association   Ontario Architecture  
resources
home
Contact Building Terms Building Styles Building Terms

Building Styles

Romanesque Revival (1840 - 1900)

Origins --- Romanesque Architecture

European and American Precedents ------Romanesque in Europe__-Richardson's Romanesque

Residential Romanesque in Ontario --- Hamilton--- Picton---
--

Civic and Commercial Romanesque in Ontario --- St. Mary's--- Woodstock--- Brockville

-- Sault St. Marie----- Gananoque----- Thunder Bay-- Toronto---- Saint Catharines

Origins

The Romanesque Revival appeared almost simultaneously in Europe and North America inspired, in part, by the writings of the critic John Ruskin who was tired of the Classical style and the Greek architectural vocabulary. Instead he promoted the Gothic style, used in most churches in Ontario between 1850 and 1950, and the Romanesque. Partly due to Ruskin and partly as one of the many revival style of the 19th century, the medieval architectural style of the eleventh and twelfth centuries was revived as the model for commercial and industrial architecture as well as civic buildings.

Romanesque Architecture

The three words that best describe the Romanesque Revival are heavy, heavy and heavy. Elements of the style include a broad, square tower, large chunky blocks, Norman or rounded arches, colonettes with elaborate capitals, and corbel tables under the eaves.

Many Romanesque Revival buildings have been left to decay or have been torn down in Ontario because, unlike the Gothic Revival and the Classical Revival buildings, people simply have no idea what this style is.

Romanesque in Europe and America

Romanesque in Europe

In Greece the styles - Doric, Ionic and Corinthian, came from specific locations. Roman building is more a series of building types imposed on a wide variety of locations, all part of a central empire. The next major style in Western Architecture was the Byzantine, started and promoted by Justinian. With the Romanesque, here is no central character that influenced the age. Instead the Romanesque was a style that developed in response to the times.

The late middle ages was a time of great hardship for all Europeans. Even those at the top were fearful of their tenuous positions. To lose power was also to lose your life and the lives of all those around you. There was no such thing as freedom from fear. People across Europe looked back to the Roman times when there was a sense of order and stability. In their search for an ordered existence, people sought sanctuary in the church which became the spiritual focus of the community as well as being the largest, most solidly built structure that would offer a safe haven in the event of attack either from bands of rogues and outlaws or organized onslaughts from neighboring city states.

Barons, knights and serfs were largely illiterate. Their function was to maintain a stable society, keep it safe, and keep it fed. For those whose interests lay in research and experiment, life in the monastery was the only answer. Only here would you be taught to read and only here would you be granted relief from the daily workings of the farm.

Romanesque in Architecture

Romanesque Revival in the United states was inspired by Henry Hobson Richardson, indeed it became his signature style. Richardson was the father of American architecture. Laying the groundwork for this new American style he chose the Romanesque period partly because it was the period that he spent most of his student years in Europe studying and partly because he felt that a style based on but not copying the Romanesque would echo the rugged individuality and constructive energy of the American people.

 

Richardson's Romanesque was a lighter and much smoother version of the rounded windows and otherwise robust and often heavy features of the earlier style. It is more a Lombard style of Romanesque than an Italian or northern.

 

Click Hotpoints for descriptions of terms in both text and images.

Salamanca Vieja (old) Cathedral

1110 - 1180


The ornament along the archivolts of the windows on the old cathedral are rounded billets in varying sizes. The cornice along the bottom of the window is also five rows of alternating billet pattern. The capitals on the columns are influenced by Moorish architecture.

The window is very deeply set with a splayed opening to allow for arrows to be shot out with little chance of the archer being hit.

 

 

Salamanca

Austin Hall Harvard H.H. Richardson

Richardson's style is characterized by dramatic semicircular arches as can be seen in this doorway at Harvard. The clusters of squat columns are adorned with massive capitals, heavily carved with foliage, animal and human forms.

Richardson's work is generally heavily rusticated. Carvings on capitals, spandrels and archways are generous and medieval in character.

 

 

Home Insurance

Boston Massachusetts

Trinity Church

Boston USA

H.H. Richardson

Richardson's most famous Boston building is Trinity church. Theis window illustrates many Romanesque design elements. The heads under the cornice, the collonettes in the window jamb, the heckered stonework, and the Byzantine window shape.

 

 

Home Insurance

Boston Massachusetts

Capital Trinity Church

Boston USA

H.H. Richardson

This capital on the front facade has a stylised eagel in front of Corinthian acanthus leaves on a clustered column. The architrave has a freize of Romanesque holy figures.

 

 

Home Insurance

Boston Massachusetts

Bayard Building

New York City

Louis Sullivan

Richardson's Romanesque was the driving force of the chicao school of architecture. Frank Lloyd Wright and louis Sullivan, among others, took it up with enthusiasm. Here Richardson's Romanesque stylization is mixed with Sullivan's flair for Art Nouveau in the Bayard Building in New York City.

 

 

Home Insurance

Boston Massachusetts

Residential Romanesque in Ontario

The Romanesque Revival residences in Ontario were inspired by H.H. Richardson who had done many beautiful private homes for wealthy patrons in Chicago and Boston. Many of the very rich families in North America were intermarried, so they could have seen such places if they belonged to a cousin or brother - in - law.

The one word that describes this style is 'heavy'. The owners wanted to give the impression of solidity and permanence. Romanesque Revival residences are almost all very large buildings with undulating rooflines, enough room to house all the necessary servants.

Hamilton

This imposing residence has all the elements of the massive Romanesque style found in civil architecture. As opposed to the delicate and refined ornament of the Gothic and Second Empire styles, the walls are fortress-like, with arched windows and very heavy extrados. The rounded surfaces are emphasized with banding. Even the windows on the domed tower have panes that curve to accentuate the rotundity of the design.

 

 

Romanesque Court House Tower Colonettes Newel Posts Band

Hamilton

This tower is part of a High Victorian home, but it is definitely Romanesque in flavour,

 

Romanesque Mansion awning Lintel Banding Extrados

Hamilton Ontario

Civic and Commercial Romanesque in Ontario

Also not surprising is the use of Romanesque Revival for city halls and court houses. Particularly in towns where there is a lot of stone such as Woodstock, Fergus and St. Mary's, these buildings seem to grow out of the earth.

The influence of Richardson is quite evident in the old Toronto City Hall in particular.

Interestingly, gargoyles which are more popularly known as a Gothic motif are rare in Gothic Revival but found frequently in Romanesque Revival.

 

St Mary's

Romanesque Revival was used extensively in public buildings to instill a sense of permanence and civic pride.

Many buildings, like the Town Hall in St. Marys, have a wonderful mixture of medieval details. Along with the round-headed windows and arches of the Romanesque period, this building displays medieval elements including the brick checkerboard patterning, scalloping, ornamental machicolations, corner towers, and heavy block sills.

Dichromatic accents and the rough finish emphasize the weight of the stone. Darker brick is also used for string courses and sill bands. Corbie steps are also used on the east façade. Even the entrance stairways are enclosed in heavy stone railings.

 

Romanesque Revival

St. Mary's Ontario

Woodstock

The Oxford County Courthouse is a late Romanesque example designed in 1892 by Cuthbertson and Fowler. The asymmetrical plan has a large square tower and regularized half-round arched openings.

The architects have made free use of the Romanesque elements distorting them to make a truly unique building. The newel posts by the front and side entrances are embellished to exaggerate the weight of the building. Heavy horizontal bands, cornices, and dentils are equally amplified. The front porches are held up by undersized colonettes.

 

Romanesque Court House

Woodstock Ontario

Woodstock

Extensive use of round arches can be seen throughout the building, but nowhere more than the side entrance. The paneled door is fit into a large round arch. The massive voussoirs of the arch are topped by the gigantic keystone. The imposts are single large blocks that span the full space between the doors and the flanking windows. All of the elements of the door are oversized.

The stone used in the building is************. Both the design and the material give it a distinctly fortress-like feeling.

 

 

Romanesque Detail

Woodstock Ontario

Woodstock

Also in Woodstock is the City Hall made in 19**.

The stones are large and rusticated with large quoins. The paired round-headed arches on the upper level are very similar to those in Byzantine buildings of the 5th and 6th centuries. These were followed by the Romanesque paired arches found in Pisa and other parts of Europe, even as far north as England as seen in Winchester.

 

 

 

Romanesque City Hall

Woodstock Ontario

Woodstock

The window on the tower of the City Hall has many Byzantine and Romanesque elements. The Roman or round-headed arch is composed of huge, oversized voussoirs. The arch itself is compound as in many doorways of the period. (See the doorway of Santa Maria dei Soffraggio in Italy, St. Denis in France, and the castle doorway in Spain.)

The arch is supported by large columns with ornate Byzantine capitals. The scotia and torus are also oversized.

The craftsmanship and attention to detail in this building are superb.

 

 

Romanesque Detail

Woodstock Ontario

Brockville

Another courthouse, this one in Brockville, uses many of the same features, but in a strikingly different way. The two main doorways are like the Woodstock example in that each has a round arch with an emphasized extrados. The windows are rectangular, but they have heavy transom bars dividing them and equally heavy string courses.

The roofline is unusual with two shaped gables and a lunette with a superimposed pediment on the frontispiece. There is carving within the lunette and also on all spandrels.

Romanesque Revival Courthouse

Brockville Ontario

Sault Ste. Marie

This stone office building is made from Red River stone, a local stone taken from the river. The building is square and solid with large arched openings on the first floor. On the second floor there are tall slender windows with transoms in groups of two, three and four. The top floor dormer has a Romanesque façade with four slender windows topped by a lunette.

The simplicity of the design and the use of straight-forward basic forms suggests that this design was a "Richardson Romanesque" , an American style developed by H.H. Richardson in the late 19th century.

Romanesque Revival

Sault Ste. Marie Ontario

Gananoque

The most outstanding feature of this church is the multi-coloured slate roof. Many features of the church are representative of Romanesque architecture. On the east end the windows in the apse are very high off the ground. This is typical of Romanesque churches that were built as houses of worship as well as the "fortress" to keep them safe from intruding armies and bandits. The church is in a basilica plan with side aisles. The exterior stone is rusticated and the walls are buttressed.

Romanesque Revival Church

Gananoque Ontario

Thunder Bay

While this doesn't have the round-headed arches characteristic of the other examples of the style, the weight and substance of this Red River stone house make it Romanesque Revival. The two-storey front portico has decorative battlementing. The vertical openings on the porch corners are reminiscent of loop holes (openings used in medieval times for shooting arrows). The front entrance and the side dormers have decorated gables, and the bay window is devoid of Classical or Gothic detailing. Examples of Romanesque Revival housing are rare. This is a beautiful example.

Romanesque House

Thunder Bay Ontario

Toronto

University College (1856) at the University of Toronto is one of the oldest Romanesque Revival buildings in Canada. The central square tower with its compound arched doorway, scalloping, and rounded windows has the sturdy, solid look that is characteristic of the style. The solid stone walls have intricate Romanesque detailing around the windows and in horizontal bands. The tower has decorative battlementing while the roof of the main building has dichromatic slate tiles and iron cresting. The building is eclectic, but the overall style with its round headed arches is Romanesque Revival.

Romanesque University Building

Toronto Ontario

Toronto City Hall

many details of this door are taken from Durham Cathedral in England. It was originally the church attached to a large and powerful monastery. As monasteries were the medieval equivalent of the university, this makes sense.

On the left column shaft is a chevron pattern, on the right is a vine or twisted pattern. These are also found in the archivolt above the door. The compound arch of the archivolt is found in many Romanesque churches throughout Europe.

The door is of wood but has authentic huge iron hinges. These were decorative, but were also a formidable size to deter people from breaking down the door. Romanesque buildings are first and foremost fortresses.

Romanesque University Building

Toronto Ontario

Old Toronto City Hall

Completed in 1899, this building is made from stone imported both from the Credit River Valley Ontario and New Brunswick. It is one of the few stone buildings in the city because there was no stone found locally.

Romanesque sculpture was all about story telling. Instead of a narrative which is usually the case, these carvings are caricatures of the many faces of mankind.

This capital illustrates the quality of workmanship found throughout the building.

Romanesque University Building

Toronto Ontario

Toronto City Hall

These are my students from last year who didn't study for the exams.

Romanesque City Hall

Toronto Ontario

Toronto City Hall

Notice that the heads are all linked with a vitruvian scroll.

Romanesque City Hall

Toronto Ontario

Toronto City Hall

Vines and leaves grow up from the bottom of the capital and into the noses of the lower figures.

 

Romanesque City Hall

Toronto Ontario

Toronto City Hall

The round headed arches are made with huge voussoirs. Each arch has a separate moulding design, all taken from English Romanesque churches.

Huge rusticated blocks form the basis for the structure. Contrast this with the ashlar finish of the Renaissance Revival.

Notice that the arch on the top right of this photo uses dichromatic stonework.

The light fixture shows the same quality of craftsmanship found on the stonework. These would originally have been gas lamps.

Romanesque City Hall

Toronto Ontario

Toronto Queen's Park

Seen from a distance, Queen's park is solid, imposing, and regal. The central front doorway has Richardson's classic three arch entrance. On the left tower is a rose window, on the right is an opening with a balcony.

Romanesque Queen's park

Toronto Ontario

Toronto Queen's Park

On the two wings of the building are large towers with superimposed windows flanked by stone turrets. The stone is all rusticated. The voussoirs, again, are substantial.

Romanesque Queen's Park

Toronto Ontario

Saint Catharine's

The exterior detailing on Romanesque buildings is not as intricate Gothic. There is minimal carving, minimal parapet detail, and the building face is relatively flat; the overall effect is one of solidity and permanence.

This church in Saint Catharines has small tower turrets on the campanile, round-headed windows, and round headed loopholes, used in medieval times to launch arrows at attackers. An impressive rose window dominates the front façade. The front door is new and nicely integrated, if not completely contextual. The building as a wonderful medieval quality.

Romanesque University Building

Saint Catharines Ontario

Romanesque Revival Extra Reading

Books

Follet, Kenneth, Pillars of the Earth, New York : Random House, 1992

Frazer, Sir James G., The Golden Bough, New York, The MacMillan Company, 1951

Grivot, Denis, Zarnecki, George, Gislibertus Sculpteur d'Autun, Paris : Trianon Press, 1960

Kritzeck, J., Peter the Venerable and Islam. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1964

Rivoira, G. T. Lombardic Architecture: Its Origin, Development and Derivatives, London: William Heinemann, 1910

Rutherford, Edward, Sarum, Baltimore : Penguin Books, 1966

Films

Mel Gibson, Braveheart

Liam Neeson, Tim Roth, Rob Roy

 

 

 

archivolt Impost Capital Modillions Balconette Paired Windows Cornice Return Cornice Return Machicolation Scalloping Tower Corbie Steps Arcaded Porch Band Railing Voussoir Keystone Parapet Rustication Apse Buttress Transom Arch Dormer Barrel Vault Iron Cresting Tower Doorway Dichromatic Tiles Battlement Bay Window Gable Gable Lunette Band Arch Quoin Turret Rose Window Tower Campanile Clock dormer acroterion Paired Round-headed Arches Banding Tower Pinacle